Pennsylvania Supreme Court strikes down partisan congressional gerrymander.
On Monday, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court invalidated the state’s congressional map, holding that it constitutes a partisan gerrymander that “clearly, plainly and palpably” violates the Pennsylvania Constitution. The court ordered the legislature and governor to devise a new nonpartisan map for the 2018 election cycle, and warned it will commission its own if the elected branches cannot agree on one. Monday’s ruling gives Democrats a real shot at winning a majority of the state’s congressional districts in November, bolstering their chances of seizing the House of Representatives.
Pennsylvania’s gerrymander has long stood out as one of the worst in the country. GOP lawmakers drew the state’s districts in 2010 to maximize their own party’s electoral success, to great effect: Although registered Democrats significantly outnumber registered Republicans in Pennsylvania, Republicans won 13 out of 18 congressional districts in 2016. An Associated Press analysis found the gerrymander gave Republicans at least three extra House seats.
In 2017, voting rights advocates sued, asking state courts to strike down the map in time for the 2018 election. Crucially, they sued exclusively under the stateconstitution, which provides a robust guarantee of free expression and association that goes beyond the federal First Amendment. The Pennsylvania Constitution also protects “free and equal” elections, enshrining a right to vote that surpasses the safeguards of the federal Constitution. A majority of the state Supreme Court—all five of its Democratic members—found that these provisions render Republicans’ gerrymander unlawful.
AdvertisementThe GOP-controlled state legislature now has until Feb. 9 to draw a nonpartisan map and submit it to Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, who must approve the plan by Feb. 15. If the legislature and the governor cannot agree on a map by that date—which seems likely given the partisan split—the court will swiftly commission its own map. The court ordered lawmakers to draw districts “composed of compact and contiguous territory” that are “nearly equal in population” and do not needlessly split up communities.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementMonday’s decision is almost entirely immune from review by the U.S. Supreme Court. The majority clarified that it based its ruling solely on the state constitution, of which it is the final arbiter. The U.S. Supreme Court can only adjudicate federal questions; it cannot overturn the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Pennsylvania Constitution. Republicans mightask the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene on the grounds that Monday’s ruling violates the federal Constitution by stripping power from the state legislature. But that claim would be an extreme long shot, as the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a similar argument out of Arizona in 2015. In all likelihood, then, Pennsylvania’s gerrymander will gone well in advance of the 2018 elections—and for the first time this decade, Democrats can finally compete in genuinely fair districts.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Best tablet deals as of August 27
- 美加宝马建升:“差不多思维”让养猪业落后!再省不要省育种
- S. Korea to send air tanker to US this week to bring COVID
- Watch: Trump caught swearing by C
- Best Labor Day headphones deals: Apple, Bose, Beats, and more on sale
- Witness Bernie Sanders' very relatable clothes chair
- Google Podcasts search might get a lot better soon
- Ocean Battery stores renewable energy at the bottom of the sea
- South Korean lawmakers brace for US election as Harris, Trump diverge on North Korea
- Elon Musk’s Boring Company tunnel didn't impress Virginia officials
- Reminder: Airbnb lets hosts put cameras inside your rental
- Haaland hits hat
- Europe now has a huge AI gap, for better or for worse
- 创放心舒心消费城市 营造和谐消费环境
- Sinner vs. Michelsen 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
- 车子跑着没劲 或是积碳“拖后腿”
- Farmers, fishers see income boost on back of aggressive government spending
- Persuading US to ease sanctions 'top priority' for implementing inter
- 尝“鲜”盛宴,等你来探!2024年清远西牛麻竹笋尝鲜季即将启幕
- Leaked image shows 'iPhone 11' with what appears to be three cameras